How Long Can My Baby Spend in a Car Seat?

I have a beautiful seven-week-old, and so far, the question that is majorly stressing me out is about infant time in a car seat. I bought a nice comfy one and the adapter to make it a travel system for my stroller. Now I’m reading things about low-level hypoxia and that they shouldn’t spend more than 30 minutes to two hours in the car seat at a time. I’m pretty confused and would love to know! If you have some thoughts or research to point me towards, that would be much appreciated.
—Madeline

Congratulations!

This is a tricky subject, and one that I think gets into a place where we give parents advice that may be impossible to follow. If your infant can be in the car for only two hours, does this mean you can never go anywhere farther than that? Does the timer reset if you go to a rest stop? As with many things, if we do not explain why the regulation is there, it’s pretty difficult for people to respect it.

In this particular case, here are some basic facts.

First, for preterm or low-birth-weight infants, car seats can be challenging because they are not appropriately sized. This makes suffocation a stronger possibility, and this group of infants is also generally at higher risk of SIDS. With a baby in this group, until they get larger, extra caution should be taken.

Second, the car seat is not an appropriate regular nighttime sleep location. In some cases, because babies may sleep well in car seats, parents will leave them in the car seat in the crib overnight. I’ve talked before about safe sleep environments, and the evidence on back sleeping in particular, which I believe is quite strong.

Neither of these answers what I think is your question, which is whether a slightly older baby can spend time in the car seat, sleeping, either in the car or stroller. A primary source for concern about this is a Journal of Pediatrics article from 2015. The authors review deaths of infants in car seats as reported to the Consumer Product Safety Commission between 2004 and 2008. There are 31 infant deaths in car seats in the data (to put that in context: there are about 20 million births during this period, and approximately 120,000 total deaths under one year).

About half of these deaths were a result of strangulation by straps and half due to suffocation. A very large share of the deaths were a result of what we would think of as improper use — an infant put to sleep in a crib, in a car seat, with several blankets, for example. I should be clear: every single one of these deaths is a tragedy that should not have happened. Having said that, the numbers are small, and virtually all occur in a use case outside of the typical “kid sleeping in the car.” As the paper says: “It is possible that most, if not all, of these deaths might have been prevented had the device been used properly and/or had there been adequate supervision.”

What does this mean? For the use case you describe, the risks seem vanishingly small and may well be outweighed by the value of being able to take a nice walk outside with a napping baby in the stroller.